Wet snow this morning in the Salt Lake City area. Very cool morning here at house with a low of 40F - impressive events given it's the last week in May!Monday, May 24, 2010
Cool Morning Here - Snow in Salt Lake City
Wet snow this morning in the Salt Lake City area. Very cool morning here at house with a low of 40F - impressive events given it's the last week in May!Sunday, May 23, 2010
More On Summer 2010 Outlook
---------------------------------------------------------------------
First: let's review the details of last year's "Outlook" as per the web briefing hosted by U of A CLIMAS late last May:
Monsoon
The 2009 monsoon in the Southwest is forecast to be early and wet. During a Web briefing Thursday, May 21, scientists from The University of Arizona; the National Weather Service (NWS); Servicio Nacional Meteorológico, Mexico’s national weather service; and the National Center for Atmospheric Research emphasized the forecast applies to June and July but becomes more uncertain for August into September.
“The large-scale signal suggests the monsoon will arrive early and will be wet and strong,” said Chris Castro, an assistant professor of atmospheric sciences at the UA. The days leading up to the rains, he said, are likely to be very hot and dry. However, recent rainfall during the third week of May was not caused by the monsoon.
The NWS forecasts a 33 to 45 percent chance of above-average rainfall in June, but the forecast becomes increasingly uncertain later in the summer, said Erik Pytlak, a NWS meteorologist in Tucson. One reason is that forecasts indicate a rapid development of an El Niño event this summer into fall, which can weaken the easterly winds characteristic of the monsoon and bring drier weather to the Southwest.
-------------------------------------------------------
As John reported in his comment - these outlooks didn't verify well at all. The summer storms and rains weren't early and the first part of summer was not wet (at least in the Tucson and Phoenix regions - I'm not sure about far southeast Arizona (Art ?). Those who read my blog last summer know that I often referred to the dismal summer weather as the "nonsoon."
------------------------------------------------------
My first question for anyone out there with an opinion: With the current, totally ambivalent, situation, should the LOCAL NWS be providing any climate forecast information, other than repeating what CPC has to say and referring questions to the "experts" at CPC?
Giant Agave Falls

Although winds around the Tucson metro area have only been gusting up to 40 mph early this afternoon, they have been strong enough to take down the magnificent agave stalk that was blooming in the courtyard. Apparently the gusts swirling around the house and garage produced too much stress for the very heavy stalk. It's a sad loss since I had hoped we could have it decorating the courtyard until next winter.Strong Cold Front

Back to some real-time weather. This morning a strong 500 mb short-wave trough is approaching central and northern Arizona (see the current NAM 500 mb forecast for 5 pm MST this afternoon - top). Strong low-level cool advection will be associated with the surface cold front that crosses Arizona during the day today (see the current NAM 850 mb forecast in lower panel). Front is coming off the Pacific fairly strong (currently 16C temperature gardient between Tucson and San Diego at 850 mb), but over the Southwest it will be fighting intense solar insolation. Looks like another dry, windy and dusty weather system - par for the course this time of year!Friday, May 21, 2010
More On The Summer Outlook


----------------------------------------------------------------
More on the NWS Summer 2010 Forecast

Conflicting signals about next monsoon
Tom Beal Arizona Daily Star Posted: Friday, May 21, 2010 12:00 am
It's going to be hot this summer, probably, and we'll have less rain or more rain than usual, according to the National Weather Service, which posted its first online monsoon briefing for 2010 on Thursday.
The North American Monsoon, a seasonal shift to southerly winds that brings moisture to the Southwest each summer from the the gulfs of California and Mexico, responds to a variety of atmospheric circumstances.
Generally, Southern Arizona receives less summer rain when the winter rains are above average, as they have been this year, said Erik Pytlak, monsoon researcher with the National Weather Service in Tucson.
That's because moist ground in the Plains states slows the heating needed to lure a high-pressure system northward from Mexico. The monsoon, which usually brings thunderstorms to Tucson by early July, won't start early and could be a little late, Pytlak said.
The monsoon could intensify later in the season, however, if the Pacific Ocean cools, a phenomenon known as La Niña - the flip-side of the El Niño warming that cut off last summer's monsoon prematurely.
Cooling oceans increase the contrast between temperatures over land and sea. As the sun warms the land, heat rises and cooler, moister air rushes in. The computer models are divided on whether the ocean-cooling phenomenon, known as La Niña, will occur.
Right now, most models call for average ocean temperatures, a condition the scientists call "El Niño neutral."
"In an El Niño-neutral year, the most likely thing to happen is near average rainfall," Pytlak said.
Officially, the National Weather Service forecasts "a 40 to 55 percent chance of above-average temperature" and "equal chances for above or below-average rainfall."
"There are conflicting signals out there now and quite a bit of uncertainty," Pytlak said.
RE NWS Summer Outlook For 2010
While this might be a somewhat out-of-context statement (I don't know one way or the other), at face value, it's just outright embarrassing for the NWS. One would think that statements like this need to be reviewed by someone capable of finding such gaffes before they're disseminated. Is that too much to ask?
Steve Mullen sent along the link to comments on the brief story posted previously:
http://dynamic.azstarnet.com/comments/viewcomments.php?id=/news/local/article_f0ed0896-6451-11df-bf32-001cc4c002e0.html&h=Weather%20Service%20posts%20Monsoon%20briefing%20for%20Southern%20Arizona
-------------------------------------------------------------------
My quick take on the brief story that reporter Tom Beal filed online yesterday is that it reflected a cynical frustration with how little real information was conveyed during a fairly long briefing. He has filed an extended story this morning.
The firestorm of mostly nasty or negative comments in reponse to the brief story posted yesterday is a bit surprising - putting the NWS summer outlook up there with some controversial policy and political issues that always have comments galore of this type.
Thursday, May 20, 2010
NWS Outlook For Summer 2010
Weather Service posts Monsoon briefing for Southern Arizona
By Tom Beal Arizona Daily Star Posted: Thursday, May 20, 2010 1:51 pm
It’s going to be hot this summer and we’ll either have more or less rain than usual, according to the National Weather Service, which posted its first online briefing for the Monsoon season today.
If you want to know why, you can listen to Weather Service monsoon expert Erik Pytlak explain it all.
Click on “2010 Monsoon Forecast Web Briefing” at http://www.wrh.noaa.gov/twc/
Tuesday, May 18, 2010
Well-Travelled Agave Does Its Thing


Have a great agave in bloom (they are generically called century plants because of how long it takes many varities to bloom) but I'm not sure of this one's exact variety. I do know it is very well-travelled. I bought it in about 1990 from Yucaa Doo Nursery northwest of Houston. So it came to Oklahoma by mail and then was planted in the backyard in Norman. Around 1996 I moved it to Tucson in a pot. Then in early 1999 it was planted in a spot in our courtyard, where it is now blooming. The stalk is about 22 feet tall by my estimate. As with most agave, this is its grand finale, and it will gradually die as the summer progresses.
Monday, May 17, 2010
Had To Turn On the Cooling Systems!


Plots are from Atmo weather station on campus. Top plot shows that breezy conditions continue to prevail here in southeastern Arizona. Bottom plot shows T and Td. After a nice cool day last Wednesday the highs have been inching up each day. I gave up this afternoon and switched the
Sunday, May 16, 2010
Early Morning Severe Thunderstorms


Very impressive bow-echo line of unusual, early morning storms out to west of Del Rio, Texas, straddling the Rio Grande. The IR satellite image at top shows a spectacular horseshoe shape of the cold tops, with an interior warm-wake. This signature nearly always is associated with storms that are severe.
Nighthawks Have Also Returned
There were two nighthawks (sometimes called bull bats) flying low and hunting insects over the house at dusk last evening. This was my first sighting of the nighthawks this year - their return is a sure sign that summer has begun here. These birds apparently winter in South America. Later in the summer I've observed as many as 20 to 40 birds within a couple of hundred yards of the house. Their erratic flight as they pick-off insects appears similar to bats and is probably where the bull bat name came from. They are quite amazing to watch as they fly very low and fast, somehow avoiding collisions.Saturday, May 15, 2010
Bats Have Returned

About 4 tiny bats make their home among the vigas of our front porch each summer. The bats returned early this week for about the eighth year. They are very small bats and start hunting insects in the early evening. They look much like butterflies when they are flying around - so much so, that I've always called them "butterfly bats." They are officially known as Western Pipistrelle bats, and they are now in residnece here at the house for the summer.Friday, May 14, 2010
This Morning's Worst RRS Soundings
Last of the Signs
Thursday, May 13, 2010
Stormy Night On Tap Across Southern New England

Quick look at the new upper-air data and latest radar indicate a stormy night for northern Pennsylvania and southern New England. Very strong low-level warm advection occurring and upstream airmass increasingly unstable. Latest radar and Pittsburgh sounding shown above. The sounding appears to not be unstable enough to support a nocturnal derecho, but situation bears watching!Lots of Storms Central U.S.
And with lots of storms activie there are a number of strange looking soundings this morning. Looks like the Minneapolis data (above) capture honors for the most bizarre RRS sounding, with the flight apparently spending some time in an updraft and then coming out with a wetted RH sensor, resulting in a serious superadiabatic layer aloft. So it goes.Wednesday, May 12, 2010
Interesting Sign

I certainly can relate. I also realize that this warning can be interpreted in many ways.
Tuesday, May 11, 2010
Stormy Night On Tap
Have just been examining this evening's 00 UTC soundings. Very substantial CAPE from north-central Texas, across most of Oklahoma, and eastward across northern Arkansas and southern Missouri. Much of this region will experience strong low-level warm advection during the coming night and substantial severe thunderstorm activity is probable, even though the afternoon has generally been supressesed. First strong storms have just developed over western Oklahoma and they may reach to southern Illinois before morning. See Springfiled, Missouri sounding above, which is primed for rapid storm development.More Comments On NWS RRS Sonde Problems
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Thanks for re-lighting the RRS fire. Something of interest for you -- we currently have a group of people from the
This suddenly was announced to us all a couple weeks ago. Very surprising, as there has been no talk of RRS sonde replacement that I've heard.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
My thoughts on this news:
Wouldn't it be helpful if NWS alerted their own internal users about what's going on! And it would be amazing if external users of NWS upper-air data were filled in on both all the problems and the long-term plans for fixing the system. I have heard rumors that they (NWS, Observing Systems Branch, Chief - joseph.facundo@noaa.gov - if any readers have questions) are moving on a fast track to replace the flawed Sippican humidity sensor, and that the entire Sippican Microsonde will eventually be replaced.
Bob
Sunday, May 09, 2010
Case Example Continued

Quick Case Example of Bad Sounding Impacts on WRF Model

Mike Leuthold sent a link to his daily WRF model discussions - it is from 4 August 2008 and it is just a quick, subjective, example of how bad RRS sounding data can affect the WRF model forecasts. I'll have to do two posts to get four graphics up here.Friday, May 07, 2010
Mike Leuthold Comments:
Questions Continued
I ask because I wonder how much balloon drift may effect the RRS PW. It is clear from the GPS data that there are rapid small scale changes occurring and I wonder if that has a big enough impact to cause the differences you are seeing. I suspect one could correlate the differences in PW to distance the balloon traveled.
An off the cuff thought was to see how inversion strength or lapse rates might affect the GPS measurement. I certianly don't think the RRS moisture sensor is error free, but the randomness might be explained by multiple factors and then you get at the systematic issues.
An interesting mystery and one worthy of exploring.
---------------------------------------------------------------------
Most of these questions/issues relate to the differences in, and the accuracy of, the two observing systems.
I consider the go-to-expert here to be Seth Gutman at the NOAA labs in Boulder.
seth.i.gutman@noaa.gov
Since the GPS calculations are using data from a number of different GPS satellites, and thereby incorporating a number of "lines of sight", I suspect that the GPS observations may be more "representative" than are the RRS (or any sounding instrument) data taken along a trajectory determined by the local winds and rate of balloon rise.
I do suspect that the first order problems with the RRS PW values relate to sensor problems of several types. Since most of the PW is present in the early part of the flight, the 4-D trajectory may contribute much less to inaccuracies, except in the case of extreme horizontal gradients.
--------------------------------------------------
Several interesting issues relate to your questions. It should be straight forward to examine the data observed in any sounding with respect to: where were the data actually taken in time and space. Of course, it is much easier to assume (falsely, of course) that the observed data are positioned directly above the release point. At some point in the fairly distant past such an assumption was easily justified - however, it is much harder to justify such an assumption given the computing power available today. I am constantly amazed that someone, or some organization, doesn't provide upper-level plots with the data properly located in space. Or, maybe someone does? The time issue is a bit tougher. I suppose that model initialization procedures could (or do?) use the observed data exactly when and where the observation occurred.
-------------------------------------------------
Another issue involves the standardized observing times for upper-air data. The reasons for taking data globally at 00 and 12 UTC were/are quite sound. However, given that 4-D data assimilation seems to drive things today, it would appear that all upper-air data might not need to be taken so rigidly wrt time. A local Arizona example - consider the NWS soundings taken near Flagstaff in the summertime. At 12 UTC in the morning the sounding typically samples an extreme surface-based temperature inversion, often making evaluation of convective potential difficult. Convective storms up in the Flagstaff area tend to occur between 11 am to 3 pm or so in the afternoon. Thus, the 00 UTC sounding is often sampling a local environment that has been contaminated by storms. The obvious question is: why not allow the Flagstaff sounding to be flown at times more in sync with forecasting local convection?
Re: Several Questions
------------------------------------------------------------------------
I don't know if the various problems with data from the RRS sondes are impacting the GFS and NAM forecasts. I would think that folks at NCEF would be evaluating these issues. At times it is obvious that bad data have gotten into the standard level analyses and you'd think that, in such situations, there would be some impact on the forecasts. Remember that the NWS official position seems to be that the data problems with RRS sondes do not impact their forecasts. However, I know that short-term forecasts of convection can be adversely affected, and there are a number of posts here over the last two summers illustrating such situations.
At U of A Atmospheric Sciences, Mike Leuthold runs a high-resolution version of the WRF model routinely. He has found that, especially in the warm season, the forecasts of convection within the model are strongly influenced by the initial precipitable water field. Since these are often inaccurate wrt to GPS precipitable water observations, he routinely uses GPS PW to "correct" the inital analyses of several NWS models.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
This winter alone it seemed as if ECMWF has consistently outperformed the GFS.(Maybe this is just my perception) I would think bad data going into a complex mathematical formula would exponetially increase errors forward in time..especially if the bad data was so random. On a side note, any thoughts on why the EC model did so well this past winter vs the GFS?
---------------------------------------------------------------------
I'm not a modeler, but even a fairly casual user of models has likely noticed that the ECMWF usually does better than the NWS GFS model (not always though, which keeps things interesting). I suspect that there are at least two things at play. The ECMWF operational time lines are not as stringent as those of NWS, and they spend more time and effort in the initialization process. I also think that the resolution of the ECMWF is superior to that of the GFS. Many folks on the Albany MAPS list could probably provide you a much better answer than I can.
Thursday, May 06, 2010
Classic Severe Storm Signature in Satellite IR Data

Severe Storms Tonight Further South Than Model predictions

Continuation of Previous Post

To continue from previous post - I also looked to the east to see how some of the sounding data were comparing to GPS data.Some Discussion Re RRS Upper-Air Data

The serious problems with data from the new NWS RRS sondes have not gone away - I've just been blogging about other things. I thought I'd return to the RRS subject, since the NWS program is nearing completion over the CONUS. I hope to finish a formal paper on the various problems I've noted with these data during the next couple of months. For now it suffices to say that upper-air data with various degrees of problems are going into the upper-air archives every day, and I repeat my warning to research users that extreme caution is required if you use these data.------------------------------------------------------------------
Wednesday, May 05, 2010
Late Spring Weather - Breezy with Large Diurnal Swings


Not much to write about these days. View north from Kitt Peak above shows early morning with dirty air trapped near the surface. Winds from the Atmo rooftop anemometer for last seven days, lower graphic, show that it's been quite windy for five of those days, with two days hitting more than 60 mph at that site.
Sunday, May 02, 2010
Quick Update to Previous Post
Not A Pretty Afternoon

At 500 mb the last, strong short-wave/vorticity max with the western US trof is now swinging across northern and eastern Arizona. Not a great afternoon, with mountain showers (see above look to the north from University campus), winds, dust, and blowing pollen. An allergy sufferer's nightmare. Winds generally gusting 30 to 50 mph this afternoon over all but far southwestern parts of the state. The plot above shows wind and gust speeds at the Atmo rooftop anemometer on campus. This afternoon shows up as considerably more gusty than yesterday, with gusts around 60 mph at this time. The coming week will be see a shift back toward more quiet weather as the storm track shifts well to the north, toward the Canadian border.Saturday, May 01, 2010
Active Severe Storm day Yesterday - High Risk Outlooked Today


There were quite a few severe thunderstorms reported yesterday in the central-Mississippi Valley - see top image. Today's outlook from the SPC indicates a high risk today for additional severe thunderstorms to occur as the central US cold front shifts slowly eastward. This pattern also continues to favor locally heavy rains and flash flooding - particularly in areas where organized storm outflows set up orthogonal to the strong southerly, low-level jet.
April Ends on Cool Note
| |||
El Niño continued its influence on the weather for Tucson during April which resulted in the first April since 2003 (65.7°) to have the average monthly temperature being below normal. This was also the coolest April since 1999 (62.3°). Rainfall was generally below normal across the metro area.. |












